Found this review in my drafts folder of my iPad and thought I'd add it to the collection.
It might be kind of a stretch, but I'm classing Shutter Island in my Boston film category because it takes place supposedly on an island in the Boston Harbor and because we recently received it on blu-ray from Netflix. Location is the only thing it will have in common with the others which are mostly Affleck brothers creations.
Martin Scorsese's attempt to create a Kubrick-esque piece of mind-bending film fell a little flat for me. In general, it was an entertaining film and I like the concept, but something wasn't quite right, despite an wonderful cast including Leonardo DiCaprio, Ben Kingsley.
The film begins with US Marshall Edward "Teddy" Daniels (DiCaprio) arriving on Shutter Island, a secure facility for the criminally insane, via ferry. His ostensible purpose, the investigation of the disappearance of a dangerous and delusional patient, but as he admits to his partner, he is really searching for his wife's killer, a man he believes to be interned on the island. Even this mission begins to give way to a deeper search for the truth as reality begins to become a moving target. He knows something is not right, but he can't quite figure out what it is.
If dead wife, Leo, and shifting reality ring bells for you, you are not alone. The themes bear a strange similarity to those in Inception, though the two films are vastly different. Still if you only want to see one, I would highly recommend Inception; I found it far superior (I reviewed it here).
Shutter Island just didn't quite transcend the ordinary. Shutter Island wasn't a bad film, but you hope for better with a combination like Scorsese and DiCaprio.